- Ask your uncle [why the butcher] isn't friendly with him
- Katrina got Horst
- Traders looked jaded
- Galbatorix the evil rider who lost his Dragon
- Thirteen forsworn
- But I don't believe that s magician with though power to transport the Stone wouldn't be able to find it again
- Elf called Eragon found a Dragon egg..
- The companionship between eragon and Saphira is pretty cool
- Can't help but imagine the Dalish Elves encampment theme from Dragon age as I read this
- "First, let no one rule your mind or body. Take special care that your thoughts remain unfettered. One may be a free man and yet be bound tighter than a slave. Give men your ear, but not your heart. Show respect for those in power, but don’t follow them blindly. Judge with logic and reason, but comment not. Consider none your superior, whatever their rank or station in life. Treat all fairly or they will seek revenge. Be careful with your money. Hold fast to your beliefs and others will listen.” He continued at a slower pace, “Of the affairs of love . . . my only advice is to be honest. That’s your most powerful tool to unlock a heart or gain forgiveness. That is all I have to say." - Garrow
- The Strangers mentally locked upon Eragon when they crouched down.. why did they flee from Brom?
- He must be a rider?
- Brom looked at Eragorn's mark.. and started humming merrily
- Would you ignore that debt?
- Mental battles and conversations are interesting
- Katrina diffidently left after putting an arm around him
- Nothing mattered anymore except the act itself. The doing is the thing.
- Because of the slaughter at Doru Areaba
- Yes. So you reached an agreement?
- So...it starts again. But how and where will it end? My sight is veiled;
- How did Brom magically appear
- It's a mistake I deeply regret, and one that has cost you dearly
- At this point you don't need to hear my history, nor have you yet earned that right
- There isn't any reason for me to trouble you with such things until you have the time and power to deal with them.
- Peace. All will be told in time.
- Objects had a unique sense of mass
- Are you hurt? Where are the ones who did this? I will tear them apart
- Don't feel bad. We all made mistakes today. Mine was not staying close enough to you
- It is the name for fire
- The language describes the true nature of things
- Mental exercises for training
- Eragorn discovered it himself
- No rider at his age has killed urgals with that kind of Magic
- Everyone has a hidden name
- Gets a bit boring..saphira conversation becomes a bit teenage angsty..
- People have an annoying habit of remembering things they shouldn't
- If anything happens I'm going to pin you to my back and never let you off. I love you too.
- Houses by the outer wall, in the front are lower to allow archers to shoot invaders without hitting comrades
- Keep in mind that many people have died for their beliefs; it's actually quite common. The real courage is living and suffering for what you believe. - eragon should pretend to serve Galbatorix?
- Chicaneries
- Your fate will be to leave this land forever
- An epic romance strong enough to outlast empires
- Look under the roots of the Menoa tree to find a weapon
- If your power is insufficient to go rock of the Kuthian
- ..of all the people in Alagaesia, he believed you were the best suited to inherit the Riders legacy
- Brom died, and Murtagh got introduced, a bit too suddenly..I didn't like the suddenness... although I get that it's designed so that Eragon's training wheel come off
- Don't insult me. The only reason I'm free is because of you. I'm not going to abandon you to the Empire....
- Your words hearten me
- Eragon a bit naive about leaving enemies alive
- Sleep or no sleep I'm seeing you to the Varden
- Interesting concept of ferrying the egg between Elves and Varden/dwarves until it hatched
- Complicated politics between Elves, dwarves and varden
- Bit too sudden and pacing isn't great - information dump at Tronjheim
- I preferred the beginning better
- Air tactics
- Interesting idea if mana - can't cast magic without it risking killing you
- Saphira's flights over the combatants gave Eragon a unique understanding of how the battle was progressing. Urgals disadvantaged by dispersal of forces
- Urgals' apparent lack of a leader- what if it's the twins??
- 4.15/5? Good start and end I guess but some middle bits could have been better. Pacing issues and Eragon always seems to black out. Feels about the same as mid Ranger's Apprentice standard
Eldest
- Ajihad dies too suddenly
- Politics of electing the next varden leader is interesting
- Jormundur wants the position but he can't openly declare unless people back him
- The Elder council want a puppet in Nasuada
- The council want to appear powerful as they do all the appointing
- You just altered the balance of power. No one will underestimate you again because if it. Beware the rotten stone. You have earned and powerful enemies today
- Trianna flirts with Eragon and Saphira protects him from being sucked in and seduced - she can read Trianna's ill intentions
- Orik and Arya dwarf and elf accompanying Eragon.. standard trope
- A helm from the dwarves and full rights
- Of all the races Elves change the least
- All three races have a hold on you
- Milk wool and meat clan sacrifice themselves in open air to give dwarves sustenance at great risk to their lives exposed to the enemy
- Arya touched his cheek with soft fingers
- Short of killing yourself, however, you can do little to change your destiny since you don't know what choices will lead you to the particular point of time that you day saw
- Surge of pure emotion
- No one had affected him in that manner before.
- Far better to be thought of as rude and capable than rude and incapable. What you see or hear if an elf one day may only be a slight move in a strategy that reaches back millennia, and may have no bearing on how that elf will behave tomorrow.
- Together they clung to each other as people crowded against them offering condolences, advice, congratulations and disapproval
- The hard glint in the women's eyes
- A woman without her inheritance
- If you love Katrina swallow your pride and do what's right for her
- Sloan is an idiot
- The Roran chapters are more tense and desperate
- Yet who watched the Watchers?
- You would do well to guard your heart
- Now is not the time to lose it
- Guard your tongue. They mean well
- A rousing speech
- Was I good enough? Good enough! You could have convinced an Urgal to become a farmer tonight
- Interesting concept of what drives the villagers to leave and concept of revenge
- The chapters where the villagers leave and pack up - or stay-are interesting
- Bring honor to your clan
- I wish that we had had a chance to talk about all of this at least once
- You cannot miss what you have never had
- Was Arya testing Eragon with her story of the Menoa tree and the younger man who cheated on the older woman
- Eragorn screwed up the life of someone else
- Meditation as a mind scan of everyone's intentions
- Magic as legalistic word choice.. the words must be precise
- Nasuada chapter and training in ellesmera is a bit boring
- Just remember that at a certain point, your enemies may have to become your allies
- Do you think so little of my judgment Eragon? Saphira picked him
- That was a fool thing to do, making up something as ridiculous as that
- Must the price of my indiscretion be our friendship?
- I cannot help how I feel toward you but I would rather suffer another wound from Durza than allow my foolishness to destroy the companionship that existed between us. I value it too highly.
- Our friendship shall endure..we shall have to wait and see what the future brings
- I have ..betrayed what it means to be a Dragon, and tarnished the honor of he Riders.
- This cannot nor ever shall be
- Pretty cool how Roran meets Jeod again
- What's done is done
- Weeding out who is secretly for the Black Hand
- End part is more exciting
- Galbatorix made an illusion that he wasn't leaving the capital
- The debate became far more acrimonious
- Eragon learns to draw energy from the environment
- bivouac
- Allies with urgals
- Roran kills the twins...inconceivable.. battle scenes are good. Murtagh a rider? What the. Should have guessed but I got the twins right. Murtagh the "Eldest"
- You have made mistakes but they are no greater than by own
- Good twist.. thought it would be Roran who betrayed him
- Eldest - title set us up well. Good use of it
- Better than Eragon only because of the twist. Maybe 4.25/5
Brisingr
- the hardest part is trying to anticipate every possible spell. I spend most of my time asking how I can protect myself if I'm attacked like this and would another magician expect me to do that
- A week: that is his long I shall wait. Then I shall return to for you Eragon even if I must fight my way pay Thorn, Shruikan, and a thousand magicians
- You have proved yourself to be Brom's heir. You seem compelled to find the deepest patch of quicksand and then dive into it
- A person's true name often changes as they age
- Nighthawk- selected from each mortal race
- Bear witness now
- Elva - interesting concept of a blessing turned wrong because of some mispronunciation
- I wish I had what they had
- eragon mouths I'm sorry and he knows Saphira bore him no ill will
- I am glad you were by my side today Eragon. And you by mine
- I am ashamed to be instructed in morality by one so less experience
- Welcome and may the wind rise from under your wings - used the same affection with Arya as Eragon
- And may the stars guard your forward path
- Interesting concept of filling items with magic and storing them
- Eragon does not trust Islanzadi and he thinks Nasuada only reports truths that best supported her position.. what if Galbatorix isnt the only bad guy or is actually protecting himself from the others who are also evil
- May the wind rise under your wings, may the sun always be at your backs, and may you catch your prey napping
- Let it escape. I only concern myself with things that exist - verbal trickery
- You have earned no favour with me today. Count me not as friend or foe. The way Elva says this sounds like she's a foe.
- Most people haggle downward..I have chosen to haggle upward.
- Helen had the detached look of a person performing an unpleasant task
- It seems to me that Brom must have discovered something in Gil'ead when he was fighting Morzan and his Dragon, something so momentous it moved Brom to abandon everything that was his life up until then
- Reading the record of the past has often provided me with courage and insight to choose the correct path
- Eragon paid his debts to Helen and Gedric. Cool part. Who can blame you if you were protecting your own necks at the same time? And for your sacrifice, I will always be grateful.
- I cannot imagine a higher honour
- Helen rushed at him and embraced him
- Eragon's heart was so full of love and Saphira did some reckless flying and Eragon reckons she can rest tomorrow but I bet something crazy happens in he next chapter that will make them regret exerting so much energy recklessly
- Galbatorix must have placed spells on those men...of this I am certain: the soldiers are more than they appear
- Elves and Arya joining their minds with Eragon
- Battlefield and political strategy
- I bet those purple veiled dwarves are going to give Eragon a hard time
- The prowess of Dragon and rider is measured by how well they work together and how well they can function when apart
- Move swiftly then, so I may soon join you in Farthen Dur
- Bottling the energy of animals being slaughtered
- Very well, Nar Garzhvog, let us run together, you and I, as has not happened in the whole of recorded history
- I like this more because there are more tactics and unexpected events
- May your enemies cower before you
- There must be a flaw in your cousin's wards - a misplaced word or a poorly reasoned statement
- I kill for my love.. for my love of Katrina, Eragon, everyone from Carvahall, the Varden, this land of ours
- Whatever you have seen or done, you will always have me
- Her smiles never reached her eyes
- I have never met anyone like you before
- Because I have thought of something you have not.. banish them
- Edric is an idiot leader..Roran saved a useless commander..classic example of defying authority / chain of command to do the right thing
- Nasuada is an idiot for letting Edric be higher up than Roran
- When the chronicles of this age are written, shall they say we fought alongside the humans and the Elves, as the heroes of old...
- The trick is finding a spell your enemy has overlooked and using it against him. No one is omniscient.. he cannot anticipate every possibility.
- Then refrain from pestering me with such questions
- 4.25/5?
Inheritance
- A bit sudden and weird with the cats
- Interesting how the prisoners of war and a huge burden given they swore oaths to Galbatorix
- Not even our most skilled enchanter could improve on your gramarye
- Zhu ge liang's empty village stratagem
- I see you
- You ought to know my name, tongueless one. If you had, you never would have dared oppose us - Angela. Who is she?!
- Elva crying
- I'm sorry she whispered
- Your apologies can't bring back Wyrden. Do better in the future and perhaps you can atone for your mistake.
- And so the Wheel turns
- All of us have risked an enormous amount in this venture, and none of us would appreciate being dictated to.
- Careful, he'll leave the pack if you can't convince him otherwise
- Galbatorix wants us to go to Urubaen
- A message passed down to members of the same race
- The spell would have to erase the memories of everyone who knew about the rock in the first place..
- A spell strong enough to make everyone forget when a name was mentioned
- Arya was shocked
- Glaedr v Solembum
- Were cats all enchanted
- Contacting Galbatorix is stupid..if you try ill kill whomever you send
- I won't let you endanger the rest of us just to satisfy your royal pride
- Galbatorix has no idea what's coming with the aid Eragon has just received from the hidden dragons!
- It may take some time to stagger our departures correctly
- Arya kissed him on the forehead
- Gets better from page 550 and onwards. Middle part a bit boring
- Fear is good in small amounts but when it is a constant pounding companion it cuts away at who you are and makes it hard to do what you know is right
- How did murtagh know the name of names? Also it's a bit of a cop out that he came to the rescue vs Galbatorix
- Arya, what is to become of us?
- I don't know
- My feelings won't change
- If they don't, then perhaps in time
- You cannot ask more of me now. I do not want to make a mistake with you
- But we don't have time
- Dragon's mating a bit random
- A film of tears appeared on her eyes. Then we will part ways.
- Her hand touched his
- The bitter-sweet romance of this novel saves it somewhat
- Quite a long time is spent on the epilogue.. not sure if I like that
- Sloan's fate is interesting
- The last few chapters is kind of like what you would do if you had all the time in the world to say goodbye to your loved ones if you knew you were permanently leaving or dying..it's a sad ending and not one I really like
- For they knew their time together was drawing to an end, and none wished to mar it with a thoughtless phrase.
- Star crossed lovers
- A bit too easy- 4/5??
The Prophecy Loophole: Fans have long pointed out that Angela’s prophecy says Eragon will leave AlagaĆ«sia and never return. But it never says Arya can't leave Du Weldenvarden to visit him. As immortal beings who will live for thousands of years, the few centuries Arya spends rebuilding the elven kingdom is just a drop in the bucket. Once the land is stable, there is absolutely nothing stopping her from flying her green dragon across the sea to be with him.
Think of this ending not as a final closed door, but as a long, mandatory intermission. They had to save the world first; now they have to rebuild it separately before they can ever explore what they could be together.